Friday 5 July 2013

Exclamatory Remarks

Exclamatory Remarks

When I think of my sorely missed colleague Gavin Wallace I think of the exclamation mark!

 Sorry let me say that again.

I think of the exclamation mark.

Gavin was the literary expert with the Scottish Arts Council. That wasn’t his job title but that’s what he was. I, like many before me, had sought his views on my own writing. And as with all those other aspirant scribblers he took the time and care to appraise, consider and critique. His most critical comment was my inappropriate and too frequent use of the exclamation mark. So now, whatever I am writing, Gavin pops up the minute I reach for that character on the keyboard. It’s always a welcome intervention. It brings to mind a man who was generous with his time, his expertise and, ironically I might say, rather free with his own exclamations. He was a most eloquent, passionate and evangelical champion of the Scottish literary world. Every aspect of that world took on a grandeur and significance whenever he spoke. Some may say it was too forgiving, uncritical. I would say let’s err on that side of generosity of spirit. It’s the positive counterpoint to the Scottish cringe, an antidote to the increasing prevalence of the Scottish whinge. Gavin suffered at its emotionally parsimonious hand himself in the occasionally disputatious world of our literary community. Some commentators invoked a tone that added little to the quality of discussion and did a lot to personalise and sometimes hurt.

 It never ceases to amaze me that in some aspects of public life, the arts included, that people get away with insult and injury that would be entirely unacceptable anywhere else.  If I had spoken to my workmates on the building sites of Lerwick in the way that some have spoken to me in the course of being an arts administrator I would have been chewing on a length of 2 by 2. I am not condoning corporal punishment for intemperate tone and critique. But I am urging a more thoughtful and, yes, forgiving approach to our civic discourse. There are many arguments to be had before we settle on our future as a country. Let’s make sure we are able to still talk to each other when that moment comes.


Other Blogs from Jim

No 1 Welcome_to_the_Saltire_Society_-_From_MacDiarmid_to_Kelman.pdf


22 September 2018

The 2018 Fletcher of Saltoun Awards announced

 the 30th annual Fletcher of Saltoun awards were announced on 22 September. Organised by the Saltire Society, this honorary award is presented annually to inspiring Scots in recognition of their outstanding contribution to Scotland’s culture and society.

Read More >


30 July 2018

Outstanding Women of Scotland 2018

Join us as at a special event announcing the 2018 Saltire Outstanding Women of Scotland.

Read More >


20 June 2018

Saltire Housing Awards 2018 Winners Announced!

Read about the winning projects celebrated at last nights awards ceremony.

Read More >


18 April 2018

Competition Seeks Best Poetry in Scots, Scottish Gaelic and English

The Saltire Society is delighted to be continuing our support of the Wigtown Scots Poetry Competition in 2018

Read More >


29 March 2018

Alasdair Gray Bursary Winner Announcement

Folksinger Iona Fyfe has been awarded the Alasdair Gray Inspring Scotland Bursary.

Read More >


19 March 2018

Inspiring Scotland Bursary sees Writer go to Brazil

Writer Helen McClory attended the Kaaysa Residency, a month long Residency in Brazil.

Read More >


30 November 2017

saltire Literary Awards Announced!

The Saltire Society Literary Awards were announced on St Andrew's Day

Read More >


30 November 2017

Saltire Publisher Awards Announced

The Saltire Society Publisher of the Year Awards were announced on St Andrew's Day

Read More >


25 October 2017

Saltire Civil Engineering Awards 2017 Announced

We were delighted to announce the 2017 Saltire Civil Engineerings Awards at a ceremony in the National Museum of Scotland on the 24October.

Read More >


18 September 2017

Dundee Contemporary Arts Centre Hosts 2017 Fletcher of Saltoun Awards

The 2017 Fletcher of Saltoun Awards were presented at the Dundee Contepoary Arts Centre this past Saturday Septmebr 16th.

Read More >


21 June 2017

Saltire Housing Design Awards Announced!

We announced our 2017 Housing Design Awards on the 21st June 2017. Find out who won what.

Read More >