|
| Panel Results |
THE SALTIRE SOCIETY HOUSING DESIGN AWARDS 2009.
To visit the Saltire Society's dedicated Housing Design Awards website and download the 2009 entry form please click here
To download the 2009 entry form in WORD format click, here.
Please send the completed form to saltire@saltiresociety.org.uk marking in the subject field Housing Design 2009 entry form.
Please register by e-mail your intention to enter to saltire@saltiresociety.org.uk
The Press release for the 2009 Awards can be viewed here.
The Saltire Society Housing Design Awards Ceremony 2008
took place on
Monday 10th November 2008
at
6.45 for 7.00 p.m.
at
The Lighthouse, 56 Mitchell Lane, Glasgow
The Guest of Honour, Stewart Maxwell, MSP
Minister for Communities and Sport will
present the Awards.
Malcolm MacLeod, FCIOB, FRICS, Past Chair CIOB
will present the CIOB Scotland Good Building Awards.
The presentations was followed by a talk entitled
'Urban Splash - Changing People's perceptions' by
Patrick Sheridan, Associate Director of Urban Splash.
Press release
(Word document).
The results can be viewed below.
Background: This award was established in 1937 to identify high quality housing
developments. At the time the panel were concerned about Scottish vernacular and
they rewarded projects that they felt contributed to keeping the traditions of rural
house building alive.
Over the last 65 years the concerns of the panel have changed with the requirements
of the housing market and broader social and political concerns. As more of the
population look for a 'home for life' and adapt that home to suit their lifestyle
at various points in their life, architects and builders are being called upon to
find creative solutions to extension and conversion problems.
The 2007 Awards were presented in The Lighthouse, Glasgow on November 12th. Press release
(Word document).
TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF ENTRY
The Awards
1. Award-winning entries will receive an illuminated diploma and a plaque for attachment to the building. Commended entries will receive an illuminated diploma. Details of all shortlisted entries will be posted on the Society's website and contribute to forming an archive of housing in Scotland.
2. A builder of award-winning or commended housing may receive an additional award on the recommendation of the Chartered Institute of Building.
3. The panel wishes to recognise excellence and innovation in housing design, and particularly projects that create a sense of place and identity within the environment in which they are located.
The projects may consist of:
o High Density Housing - over 50 dwellings per hectare
o Low Density Housing - 20 to 50 dwellings per hectare
o Small Works.
All three categories will be open to public and private works.
Entry Requirements
4. Entries are restricted to work completed in Scotland in 2008.
5. Entries may be submitted by owners, builders, developers, architects, architectural technicians, public or semi-public bodies, and individuals who have commissioned works in Scotland.
6. Entry Fee: £50.00 (including VAT)
7. A well designed housing or residential project will acknowledge its situation, be fit for purpose, coherent, adaptable, sustainable in the widest sense and, last but not least, bring delight to its users and enhance the quality of their lives.
8. In "Firm Foundations", the recent public consultation on housing by the Scottish Government, concern was expressed about the quality and impact of residential developments. The Panel shares this concern and would welcome submissions from the private sector and others that:
o Involve multiple tenures
o Involve multiple housing providers
o Address place-making
o Address sustainability
9. A clearly distinct stage of a large development which has already received an award is eligible for an extension award.
10. While all types of construction will be considered, the Panel wishes to encourage good design in timber frame housing.
How to Enter
11. Entry form and information sheets 1, 2, & 3 should be completed and electronically submitted on CD together with 2 sets of drawings and images at 300dpi and 72dpi resolution respectively, making them suitable for exhibition, publication, archiving, and posting on The Saltire Society website.
The CD should contain:
o Drawings:
location map with OS references & postcode
site layout plan
block plans
house/flat layout plans
elevations, sections etc
o Photographs:
a total of no more than 6 at 300dpi (tiff) and
72dpi (tiff) resolutions.
o Information Sheet 1:
list of the project team
o Information Sheet 2:
a description of the project, covering the client's brief, features of the site,
numbers and mix of dwelling types and house design, on a single A4 sheet:
CDs should be clearly labelled with the year of your submission, the name of the
entrant and the title of the project.
Accompanying the CD, entrants must also supply a clearly-titled loose leaf A4 file
containing paper copies of all the entry material, including computer prints of the
photographs.
12. The Saltire Society may wish to retain all entry material for record,
publication or exhibition purposes, including posting on the Society's website.
Entrants should make themselves and their team aware that, by way of entry, they
give their consent to this requirement and sign the entry form accordingly.
The Society cannot enter into correspondence about the results.
Housing Panel
Simon Winstanley (Convener)
Clare Armstrong (Secretary)
Karen Anderson
Alison Blamire
Alistair Dickson
Ian Gilzean
Angus Kerr
Alan Lundmark
Malcolm Macleod
Vernon Monaghan
David Page
Jane Paterson
Alasdair Stephen
Adrian Welch
Jim Whiston
Alasdair Wylie - Representing CIOB
The Results:
All entrants will be informed of the results at an award ceremony,
to which they will be invited.
| Year |
Category |
Award/Commendation |
Location |
Architect |
Builder |
| 1999 |
New Housing General |
Award |
Moffat Gardens, Gorbals, Glasgow |
Page and Park Architects/Elder & Canon Architects |
John Dickie Construction Ltd |
| |
New Individual Houses - Urban |
Award |
St. Francis Friary, Gorbals, Glasgow |
Page and Park Architects |
John Dickie Construction Ltd |
| |
New Housing and Private Sector |
Commendation |
1-4 Slater’s Steps, Holyrood Road, Edinburgh |
Ungless & Latimer Architects |
Hart Builders (Edinburgh) Ltd |
| |
New Individual Houses - Rural |
Commendation |
Bemersyde, Nr Melrose |
Morris and Steedman Architects |
CM Welsh Building Services |
| |
New Housing General |
Commendation |
Dumbarton Road, Glasgow |
Anderson Christie Architects |
JB Bennet (Contracts) Ltd |
| |
New Housing General |
Commendation |
Kittybrewster Square, Aberdeen |
Halliday Fraser Munro |
Stewart Milne Construction |
| 2000 |
New Housing General |
Award |
112 Canongate, Edinburgh |
Richard Murphy Architects |
Robert Rollo & Sons, Builders |
| |
New Housing General |
Award |
10,20 30 Graham Street, Glasgow |
Page and Park Architects |
John Dickie Construction Ltd |
| |
New Housing General |
Commendation |
375-411 Wellshot Road, Glasgow |
Elder & Cannon, Architects |
D Campbell & Company, Builders |
| |
New Housing and Private Sector |
Award |
Homes for the Future Villa 1999 |
RMJM Scotland Ltd, Architects |
Riverbrae Construction |
| |
New Housing and Private Sector |
Award |
Homes for the Future The Green, Glasgow Green |
Elder & Cannon, Architects |
John Dickie Construction |
| |
New Housing and Private Sector |
Commendation |
"Dublin Colonies", Dublin Street Lane North, Edinburgh |
Richard Murphy, Architects |
Watson Construction Ltd |
| |
New Housing and Private Sector |
Commendation |
Homes for the Future, 14-16 Lanark Street, Glasgow |
Rutherford/Austin Smith Lord, Architects |
MacTaggart & MickelWren |
| |
Restoration, Reconstruction |
Commendation |
31 Chambers Street, Edinburgh |
Lee Boyd Partnership, Architects |
Barry D Trentham Ltd. |
| 2001 |
|
Award |
New Housing at Locharthur |
Crallan & Winstanley, in association with Camphill Architects |
T Graham & Son Ltd |
| |
|
Award |
Crown Street 2A, Gorbals, Glasgow |
Page & Park |
John Dickie Construction Ltd |
| |
|
Award |
Crown Street 3A, Gorbals, Glasgow |
Elder & Cannon |
John Dickie Construction Ltd |
| |
|
Award |
New Build 3, Graham Square, Glasgow |
McKeown Alexander |
John Dickie Construction Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
Terrace and Object Building, Homes for the Future, Lanark Street, Glasgow |
McKeown Alexander |
Ballast Construction Scotland |
| |
|
Commendation |
Stanley Mills, Near Perth at Stanley |
Law & Dunbar Naismith |
Barry D Trentham Ltd. |
| 2002 |
2002 Design Awards Pamphlet in Acrobat format |
Award |
Wightman House, 15 Sciennes Gardens, Edinburgh |
Malcolm Fraser Architects |
Inscape Joinery |
| |
|
Award |
The Park, Holyrood Road, Edinburgh |
Campbell & Arnott |
Teague Homes |
| |
|
Commendation |
Tigh na Drochaide, Isle of Skye |
Neil Stephen |
J & W Cook |
| |
|
Commendation |
Spence House, 22 Spylaw Road, Edinburgh |
Malcolm Fraser Architects |
James Turner & Co |
| |
|
Commendation |
Cardy Net House, Lower Largo |
Hurd Rolland Partnership |
Andrew Cook/ Ken Garland |
| |
|
Commendation |
Crown Street, Aberdeen |
Macmon Architects |
Stewart Milne Homes |
| |
|
Commendation |
The Long House, Wemyss Bay Paul Stallan |
RMJM |
David Pearson with Robert Ryan Homes |
| |
|
Commendation |
The Terraces, Clydebank, Glasgow |
Anderson Bell Christie |
Carillion |
| 2003 |
|
Award |
Samaritans Hospital, Glasgow |
Vernon Monaghan |
D Campbell & Company |
| |
|
Award |
Murdoch Nisbet Court, Newmilns, Ayrshire |
Page & Park |
McTaggart Construction Ltd |
| |
|
Award |
Dundonald, Ayrshire |
Wren Rutherford A-S:L |
J B Bennett (Contracts) Ltd |
| |
|
Award |
Mayar Bhan, West Kilbride |
Kevin & Catherine Cooper |
Gordon Middleton |
| |
|
Award |
Merchiston Mews, Edinburgh |
Arcade Architects |
Richard Street Ltd |
| |
|
Award |
Royal Park Terrace, Edinburgh |
Zone Architects |
David Francey Joinery |
| |
|
Award |
Hart Street, Edinburgh |
Zone Architects |
Reywood Construction Ltd |
| |
|
Award |
The Granary, Elie |
McKeown Alexander |
Kelmac |
| |
|
Commendation |
The Windsor Hotel Site, Dunoon |
Elder & Cannon |
John Brown (Strone) Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
Ferry Road, Edinburgh |
Oliver Chapman Architects |
Campbell & Smith Construction Ltd |
| 2004 |
|
Award |
Old Fishmarket Close, Edinburgh |
Richard Murphy Architects |
John Mowlem |
| |
|
Award |
Lotte Glob House |
Gokay Deveci |
Kenny MacRae & Sons, Joiners and Funeral Directors |
| |
|
Award |
The Icon, Glasgow |
Elder & Cannon |
Melville Dundas Ltd (In Receivership) |
| |
|
Award |
Succoth Avenue, Edinburgh |
Reiach and Hall |
AMA (Construction) Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
The Tanks, Wormit |
Pask Architects |
Stuart Elder |
| |
|
Commendation |
The Drum, Bo'ness |
Vernon Monaghan |
Ogilvie Construction Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
Queen Elizabeth Gardens |
Elder & Cannon |
Ogilvie Construction |
| |
|
Commendation |
Ronaldson's Wharf, Leith |
Dignan Read Dewar and Fraser Brown McKenna |
Tannson Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
Tarland, Aberdeenshire |
Rasmussen Levie Architects |
George McDonald |
| |
|
Commendation |
Minnow House, Edinburgh |
Nicholas Groves-Raines |
Peter Walker Contruction |
| 2005 |
pic1
pic2
Press release |
Award |
The Drum Phase 3, Bo'ness |
Malcolm Fraser Architects |
Stewart Milne Homes |
| |
pic |
Award |
House in Ross-shire |
Brennan & Wilson Architects |
Allan McDonell, Builder and Joiner |
| |
|
Commendation |
Extension at 12 Broomhill Place, Glasgow |
Studio KAP Architects |
Standard Construction |
| |
|
Commendation |
Glenboig Cottage, Fintry |
Studio KAP Architects |
R G Chalmers Ltd. |
| |
|
Commendation |
Conversion of The Press, Edinburgh |
Duffy & Batt |
Dennis Walton |
| |
|
Commendation |
The Stable Block, Binny House, Ecclesmachen |
Crichton Wood Architect |
Stewart Henderson (Stonemason) |
| |
|
Commendation |
A'Chrannag, Rothesay |
Gokay Deveci Chartered Architect |
Stewart & Shields Ltd. |
| |
|
Worthy of mention |
The Matrix - Glasgow |
|
|
| |
|
|
Couston Castle Extension - Otterson Loch |
|
|
| |
|
|
Flats at North Werber Park - Edinburgh |
|
|
| |
|
|
Larch Sun Room Granby Road - Edinburgh |
|
|
| |
|
|
Housing at Joppa - Ayrshire |
|
|
| |
|
|
Croft of Clachaig - Grantown |
|
|
2006 |
|
Award |
Three Seton Mains |
Paterson Architects |
John A Smith & Son |
| |
|
Award |
Signal Station House, North Queensferry |
ICOSIS Architects |
Hutton & Read |
| |
|
Highly Commended |
Housing at Crammond, Phase 1, Crammond Road North, Edinburgh |
Richard Murphy Architects |
AMA (Construction) Limited |
| |
|
Highly Commended |
Paragon, Queen Elizabeth Square, Glasgow |
CZWG Architects |
Cruden Buildings & Renewals Ltd |
| |
|
Highly Commended |
White Cottage, Ballintuim, Blairgowrie |
Crichton Wood Architects |
Horton & Sons, Auchinleck |
| |
|
Commendation |
10A Circus Lane, Edinburgh |
Richard Murphy Architects |
Inscape Joinery |
| |
|
Commendation |
Regent Terrace, Edinburgh |
Richard Murphy Architects |
Inscape Joinery |
| |
|
Commendation |
The Holm |
Crallan & Winstanley Architects |
Galloway Timbers Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
Friary Court, Elizabeth Gardens, Gorbals, Glasgow |
Page and Park; Architects |
Miller Homes (Scotland West) |
| |
|
Commendation |
Seabank |
Lord LLP: Architects |
Barr Construction |
| |
|
Commendation |
Dean Bank Lane, Edinburgh |
Richard Murphy Architects |
Rutland Design & Build |
| 2007 |
|
Award |
St Vincent Place, Silvermills, Edinburgh |
Reiach & Hall Architects and Oberlander Architects |
HBG Construction |
| |
|
Award |
Upper Strand, Granton Waterfront, Edinburgh |
Reiach & Hall Architects and Elder & Cannon Architects |
Carillion |
| |
|
Award |
The Cottages, Silverhills, Rosneath |
Anderson Bell Christie |
Stewart & Shileds Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
Telford Drive, Edinburgh |
Gordon Murray & Alan Dunlop Architects |
J. Smart & Co. |
| |
|
Commendation |
Princess Gate, Edinburgh |
Malcolm Fraser Architects |
Talyor Woodrow Developments |
| |
|
Commendation |
Smithy Houses, Smithy Brae, Kilmacolm |
Graeme Andrew ata STUDIO & Monica McCarey |
various |
| |
|
Commendation |
Miller Street, Hamilton |
Hypostyle Architects |
Kelvin Homes |
| |
|
Commendation |
70 Hill Street, Garnethill, Glasgow |
Elder & Cannon Architects |
Chard Construction |
| |
|
Commendation |
George Place, Greenan, Ayr |
Roan Rutherford - Austin Smith Lord |
Central Building Contractors |
| 2008 |
|
Award |
BALLATER STREET / WADDELL STREET, social housing, Gorbals, Glasgow |
Page / Park |
Campbell Consortium Group. |
| |
|
Award |
FOUR HOUSE DEVELOPMENT, Coishletter, Edinbane, Isle of Skye |
Rural Design |
N.J. & J. Macfarlane. |
| |
|
Award |
DOONHOLM, low density social housing, Ayr. |
Austin-Smith: Lord |
Ashleigh (Scotland) Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
HOPE, private house near Pathhead, Mid Lothian. |
ICOSIS Architects |
John Winthrop Ltd |
| |
|
Commendation |
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, Isle of Gigha |
C.P. Architects |
D.P.C. Consortium |
